Water Heater Replacement in New York, NY
Tell us what you need. Our AI helps you build a professional brief for vetted installers, and our team verifies it. Once the quotes roll in, our system automatically compares them so you get a detailed comparison of the best options.
How it works
AI-assisted job brief
Describe your water heater replacement project using the AI assisted chat below. Our system transforms your answers into the perfect brief for local professionals.
Smart quote comparison
Local contractors bid on your project while our AI analyzes every offer. We highlight the top three recommendations and provide a detailed comparison so you can choose with confidence.
Connect and book
You get the full contact details for every installer who submitted a quote. Call your top match or any of the others to chat through the job details and get it scheduled.
AI-assisted job brief
Water Heater Replacement · New York, NY
Vetted professionals for Water Heater Replacement in our network are ready to quote.
Local insights
We mapped the market so you don't have to
We fetched water heater replacement businesses in and around New York, NY from online sources, then analysed ratings, review volumes, and recent feedback with AI to surface patterns and a side-by-side comparison. Skim the numbers below, then scroll for the full rundown, review notes, and FAQs.
Snapshot - in and around New York, NY.
15
Suppliers in scope
4.9
Avg. Google rating
6,213
Reviews analysed
At a glance
New York, NY Water Heater Replacement suppliers
Compare local water heater replacement suppliers around New York, NY in one place. Each item shows star ratings, total reviews, distance from the centre of New York, NY, and an AI-assisted analysis of real customer feedback.
Anton Plumbing Heating & Cooling
Google: 4.9 / 5 · 67 reviews · 2.9 km from search centre
AI-assisted analysis of public reviews:
Reviewers consistently praise professional service, clear communication, and solid value rather than bargain-basement pricing. They also mention punctual crews, clean work, and strong follow-through on bigger projects like tankless water heaters.
Consider It Done Plumbing, Water Heaters, and Drain Cleaning
Google: 5.0 / 5 · 369 reviews · 6.1 km from search centre
AI-assisted analysis of public reviews:
This company stands out for fast response on urgent calls and a willingness to return until the job is finished correctly. Reviewers also highlight clean workmanship, fair pricing, and helpful explanations that build trust.
Garden State Water Heaters
Google: 4.8 / 5 · 227 reviews · 0.0 km from search centre
AI-assisted analysis of public reviews:
Feedback centers on water-heater-specific expertise, quick scheduling, and crews that work neatly and respectfully in the home. Reviewers repeatedly mention responsive communication, clear pricing explanations, and competitive quotes.
Aladdin Plumbing Corp.
Google: 4.9 / 5 · 834 reviews · 0.0 km from search centre
AI-assisted analysis of public reviews:
Customers describe Aladdin as dependable over many years, with technicians who diagnose tricky heating and plumbing issues thoroughly. Reviews also emphasize on-time arrivals, quick office response, and clear explanations.
Schaaf Plumbing & Heating Inc
Google: 4.8 / 5 · 210 reviews · 12.8 km from search centre
AI-assisted analysis of public reviews:
Reviewers emphasize prompt service, efficient installs, and crews that leave the area notably clean. Water heater and heating jobs also get praise for fast turnaround, reasonable cost, and professional handling of awkward installations.
A&E NYC Plumbing
Review noteGoogle: 5.0 / 5 · 145 reviews · 0.6 km from search centre
AI-assisted analysis of public reviews:
Most excerpts praise fast response, fair pricing, and clear communication from Paul and the team. The review sample is mixed, though, with one detailed complaint questioning workmanship and follow-through.
First Choice Plumbing, Heating, Air Conditioning & Electrical
Google: 4.9 / 5 · 1,574 reviews · 36.1 km from search centre
AI-assisted analysis of public reviews:
This is a high-volume operation with repeated praise for knowledgeable staff, polished installs, and spotless cleanup. Reviewers also like the scheduling speed, proactive arrival updates, and clear explanation of options.
Kevin The Plumber Plumbing & Heating LLC
Google: 5.0 / 5 · 69 reviews · 10.7 km from search centre
AI-assisted analysis of public reviews:
Customers repeatedly describe Kevin as responsive, honest, and easy to trust on urgent or last-minute work. Reviews also mention clean execution, clear explanations, and fair pricing without pressure.
M&A Plumbing & Heating
Google: 4.9 / 5 · 76 reviews · 7.0 km from search centre
AI-assisted analysis of public reviews:
Reviewers highlight very fast response for failed water heaters and boilers, often with next-day or same-day help. They also note reasonable pricing, friendly service, and clear explanations for complicated setups.
All Clear Plumbing
Review noteGoogle: 4.9 / 5 · 316 reviews · 16.6 km from search centre
AI-assisted analysis of public reviews:
Most reviews praise quick dispatch, thorough troubleshooting, and friendly technicians who explain repairs well. The sample also shows one serious complaint about a poorly installed line and weak warranty follow-up, so consistency is worth checking.
Bargotti Co. Plumbing & Hvac
Google: 4.9 / 5 · 80 reviews · 5.6 km from search centre
AI-assisted analysis of public reviews:
Bargotti gets strong marks for responsiveness, especially on weekend or emergency calls, along with reasonable pricing and no surprise fees. Reviewers also appreciate patient explanations and a trustworthy small-business feel.
Water Heater Replaced by N.J. Electric, Plumbing & HVAC
Google: 5.0 / 5 · 149 reviews · 90.0 km from search centre
AI-assisted analysis of public reviews:
This company’s feedback is tightly focused on water heater replacement, with reviewers praising same-day service and tidy work. Communication, permit handling, and courteous service come up repeatedly as strengths.
24 Hr. Emergency Plumbing & Hot Water Heater
Google: 4.9 / 5 · 645 reviews · 7.2 km from search centre
AI-assisted analysis of public reviews:
Reviews point to prompt emergency response, clean installs, and smooth coordination around hot water heater work. Customers also mention reasonable pricing and clear communication throughout the job.
Jeffrey Burke Plumbing and Heating LLC
Review noteGoogle: 4.9 / 5 · 1,236 reviews · 48.5 km from search centre
AI-assisted analysis of public reviews:
The broader pattern is strong on prompt scheduling, professionalism, and clear explanations, including water heater replacements. One detailed negative review raises concerns about incomplete service notes and poor follow-up, so it may be worth reading recent low-star feedback directly.
First Choice Plumbing, Heating, Air Conditioning & Electrical (Hackensack)
Google: 4.9 / 5 · 216 reviews · 19.3 km from search centre
AI-assisted analysis of public reviews:
Reviewers consistently praise this branch for responsive scheduling, efficient installation teams, and careful cleanup. They also highlight fair pricing, punctual arrivals, and strong project management on larger heating and hot-water work.
Cross-Review AI Analysis
What locals are saying in New York, NY
AI-powered analysis of all of the customer reviews from multiple suppliers in the area.
Across these New York-area water heater replacement options, the strongest common positives are fast response, clear communication, and clean installation work. Many reviewers specifically mention same-day or next-day help for failed heaters, which suggests this is a fairly competitive market for urgent replacements. Several companies also earn praise for explaining options in plain language and keeping pricing reasonable or transparent, which matters when a heater fails unexpectedly. Cleanup and respect for the home come up often, especially with installers who use drop cloths or remove debris afterward. The caution signals are relatively limited, but when complaints do appear they tend to focus on workmanship consistency or weak follow-up after an installation problem. Review volume varies a lot, from smaller owner-led shops with glowing feedback to very large operators with hundreds of reviews. Overall, buyers here appear to have a healthy mix of specialized water-heater firms, established plumbing companies, and larger full-service HVAC/plumbing shops.
AI review notes
What public reviews mention in New York, NY
A&E NYC Plumbing
- One reviewer described damage during the visit and felt the technician brushed it off.
- One reviewer questioned the technician's training and problem-solving on a plumbing task.
- One reviewer said follow-up and alternative solutions were lacking after the issue was not completed.
All Clear Plumbing
- One detailed review described a sump discharge installation that repeatedly froze and cracked.
- The reviewer said crews gave conflicting assessments of the same setup.
- The reviewer felt the company did not stand behind the original work and pushed a paid redo without confidence.
Jeffrey Burke Plumbing and Heating LLC
- One detailed review alleged promised condenser cleanup was not completed.
- The reviewer said service notes and on-site communication did not match what was observed.
- The reviewer reported no meaningful follow-up after raising the concern.
Local questions in New York, NY
Based on the supplied reviews, Consider It Done Plumbing, Garden State Water Heaters, M&A Plumbing & Heating, and 24 Hr. Emergency Plumbing & Hot Water Heater all have very direct praise tied to water heater replacement work. If you prefer bigger review volume, Aladdin Plumbing Corp., First Choice, and Jeffrey Burke also have strong reputations, though some of their sampled feedback is broader plumbing or HVAC work.
Consider It Done gets especially strong emergency feedback, including a reviewer who said a water heater was replaced within 24 hours after a late-night call. M&A Plumbing & Heating, Schaaf Plumbing & Heating, and Water Heater Replaced by N.J. Electric, Plumbing & HVAC also have reviews describing same-day or next-day turnaround when a heater failed.
Consider It Done, Anton Plumbing Heating & Cooling, Kevin The Plumber, and First Choice all have multiple mentions of staff explaining issues clearly and keeping customers informed. Water Heater Replaced by N.J. Electric, Plumbing & HVAC also stands out in the sample for step-by-step updates and straightforward communication during replacement work.
Yes. A&E NYC Plumbing has one detailed 1-star review in the sample alleging poor workmanship and no useful follow-up, even though the listing rating is still very high overall. All Clear Plumbing and Jeffrey Burke Plumbing and Heating LLC also each have a detailed negative review in the supplied excerpts, so those are worth a closer look on Maps before deciding.
Speed, cleanliness, and professionalism show up again and again in these reviews. People also care about whether the installer explains the setup, gives a fair quote, handles awkward access, and follows through if the job needs another visit.
A smaller review count can still be meaningful if the comments are detailed and consistent, especially for niche water-heater work like Garden State Water Heaters or M&A Plumbing & Heating. Larger counts from companies like Aladdin, First Choice, 24 Hr. Emergency Plumbing, and Jeffrey Burke can provide more confidence in consistency, but it is still smart to scan for any repeated complaint themes.
Garden State Water Heaters, Schaaf Plumbing & Heating, First Choice, and 24 Hr. Emergency Plumbing all have explicit praise for neat work and cleanup after the job. Anton Plumbing and Kevin The Plumber also get positive comments about professionalism and respectful service, though the wording is a little broader.
Estimate water heater replacement cost in New York, NY
Rough guide based on US averages. Real quotes vary by site, finish and contractor.
Estimates are indicative only. For an accurate price, get free quotes from local contractors above.
General information
Water Heater Replacement in New York, NY
Your Local Solution for Water Heater Needs
Finding the right water heater replacement service in New York, NY has never been easier. Supertrades connects homeowners like you with trusted local contractors who can provide competitive quotes for water heater installation and replacement. Whether you need a standard tank or a tankless system, our network of professionals is ready to help you.
Understanding Water Heater Replacement Costs
When considering a water heater replacement, it’s important to understand the costs involved. A typical 50-gallon gas water heater replacement averages around $1,850, with prices generally ranging from $1,480 to $2,220. If you're opting for a 40-gallon electric heater, expect to pay approximately $1,800. We can help you compare quotes to find the best deal.
Benefits of Tankless Water Heater Installation
Tankless water heaters are becoming increasingly popular in New York, NY for their energy efficiency and convenience. These systems heat water on demand, which means you won’t run out of hot water during peak usage times. However, proper installation is key, and our contractors are experienced in tankless water heater installation to ensure you get the maximum benefits.
- Compare quotes from local contractors
- Receive personalized service tailored to your needs
- Access to experts in tankless and traditional water heater installations
- Transparent pricing with no hidden fees
How contractors price
1 / 3
Type
Tank, tankless, or heat pump.
Frequently asked questions
It is recommended to flush your water heater at least once a year to eliminate sediment buildup.
You can connect with local plumbers for water heater repairs in New York, NY through Supertrades.
To find the appropriate size for your water heater, consider both the number of people in your household and your hot water consumption habits.
A tankless water heater heats water only when it is needed, eliminating the need for a storage tank.
Some plumbers might favor traditional water heaters due to their straightforward installation process and lower initial costs compared to tankless systems.
Yes, you can run two showers simultaneously with a tankless water heater, but it depends on the unit's flow rate and capacity.
For four bathrooms, you typically require a tankless water heater with a flow rate of at least 7-8 gallons per minute.
If you have a water softener, you should flush your tankless water heater every 12 months to keep it running efficiently.
The installation cost for an electric tankless water heater averages around $1,900, while a gas unit is approximately $4,800.
Replacing a standard 50-gallon gas water heater costs about $1,850, with most replacements ranging from $1,200 to $3,500.
The installation price of a 50-gallon gas water heater is $1,850, which includes labor costs.
Lowe's installation prices are competitive. A 50-gallon gas tank installation costs around $1,850, while a 40-gallon electric tank is about $1,800.
Replace water heaters in New York, NY?
Homeowners in New York, NY are already requesting quotes for this work. Join the network and we'll email you job briefs for your area.
- Job briefs straight to your inbox
- Only jobs in the cities you cover
- Takes about 2 minutes to join